Blown save vs Hold in Sports - What is The Difference?

Last Updated Feb 2, 2025

Hold is a fundamental concept in sports, business, and everyday life, representing control or maintenance of a position or state. In athletics, a hold can refer to a defensive move or securing a lead, while in business, it might signify maintaining a strategy or position in the market. Discover how mastering the art of holding can enhance your performance and decision-making by reading the full article.

Table of Comparison

Aspect Hold Blown Save
Definition Relief pitcher maintains lead without finishing the game Relief pitcher fails to maintain lead, allowing opponent to tie or take lead
Outcome Team keeps lead; pitcher credited with hold Team loses lead; pitcher charged with blown save
Pitcher's Role Setup pitcher or middle reliever Closer or relief pitcher
Game Situation Pitcher enters with a lead and exits without losing it Pitcher enters with a lead and allows runs resulting in lost lead
Statistical Impact Positive impact on pitcher's hold stats Negative impact on pitcher's save and earned run statistics

Understanding the Hold in Baseball

A Hold in baseball is credited to a relief pitcher who enters the game in a save situation, records at least one out, and maintains the lead without finishing the game, distinguishing it from a Blown save where the pitcher loses the lead. The Hold statistic highlights the effectiveness of setup pitchers in bridging the gap between starters and closers, emphasizing their role in preserving victories. Understanding the Hold involves recognizing its impact on team strategy and pitcher evaluation beyond traditional saves and wins.

What Constitutes a Blown Save?

A blown save occurs in baseball when a relief pitcher enters a save situation but fails to maintain the lead, allowing the opposing team to tie or take the lead. Key factors include surrendering runs, issuing critical walks, or giving up hits that directly result in the losing team scoring. This contrasts with a hold, where the pitcher preserves the lead without finishing the game, maintaining the team's advantage in high-pressure relief appearances.

Key Differences: Hold vs Blown Save

A Hold is credited to a relief pitcher who enters the game in a save situation, maintains the lead, and records at least one out without finishing the game, while a Blown Save occurs when the pitcher allows the tying run or the lead to be lost during their appearance. Holds emphasize preserving the lead for the closer, often in high-leverage innings, whereas Blown Saves highlight failed save opportunities that can shift game momentum. Statistical tracking of Holds and Blown Saves provides insight into a relief pitcher's effectiveness and ability to maintain team leads under pressure.

The Role of Relief Pitchers

Relief pitchers play a crucial role in securing a hold or blown save by maintaining lead stability during critical game moments. A hold is credited when a reliever enters with a lead and records at least one out without relinquishing the lead, emphasizing the pitcher's ability to handle high-pressure situations. Conversely, a blown save occurs when a relief pitcher surrenders the lead, highlighting the importance of bullpen depth and effectiveness in preserving team leads.

Historical Context of the Hold Statistic

The Hold statistic, introduced in the late 1980s and popularized in the early 2000s, was created to credit relief pitchers who maintain a lead before handing the game over to a closer, differentiating their contributions from saves. Unlike saves, which are awarded only when a pitcher finishes a game under specific conditions, holds track middle relievers and setup pitchers who preserve leads in crucial innings without finishing the game. This metric grew in relevance as the specialization of bullpen roles expanded, allowing for more accurate assessment of relievers' effectiveness beyond traditional wins and saves.

Impact of Blown Saves on Team Performance

Blown saves directly affect a team's win probability by allowing opponents to erase late-inning leads, often leading to momentum shifts and increased pressure on the bullpen. Teams with higher blown save occurrences typically experience lower overall winning percentages due to the erosion of bullpen reliability and team morale. Effective management of hold situations and minimizing blown saves are crucial for maintaining competitive advantage and maximizing postseason potential.

Situational Examples: Hold and Blown Save Scenarios

A hold is awarded to a relief pitcher who enters in a save situation, records at least one out, and maintains the team's lead without finishing the game, such as entering in the seventh inning with a two-run lead and preserving it through the inning. A blown save occurs when a relief pitcher enters in a save situation but surrenders the lead, like allowing a go-ahead run in the eighth inning or later, causing the team to lose the lead they previously held. Situational examples include a closer blowing a save by allowing a game-tying home run in the ninth inning, contrasted with a setup man earning a hold by retiring the side in the eighth inning with the lead intact.

Statistical Significance in Modern Baseball

In modern baseball, the statistical significance of holds versus blown saves lies in their impact on a team's bullpen effectiveness and win probability added (WPA). Holds, credited to setup pitchers who maintain leads before the closer, reflect reliability in high-leverage situations, while blown saves indicate failures to preserve leads, directly correlating with increased opponent comeback chances. Advanced metrics like leverage index and WPA emphasize the critical role of holds in sustaining team momentum and overall bullpen performance efficiency.

Notable MLB Players: Holds and Blown Saves Leaders

Notable MLB players with the highest holds include Koji Uehara, who revolutionized the setup role with his 263 career holds, while leading blown saves are often associated with relievers like Bob McClure, who recorded 53 blown saves despite a lengthy career. Jonathan Papelbon ranks prominently in holds and blown saves, accumulating 231 holds alongside 10 blown saves, illustrating the volatility of late-inning relief roles. These statistics emphasize the critical balance between preserving leads and the high-pressure nature of saves in Major League Baseball bullpens.

Strategic Implications for Managers

Hold and blown save metrics provide critical insights into relief pitchers' performance, directly influencing managerial decisions on bullpen utilization and game strategy. Managers leverage hold statistics to identify reliable setup pitchers who maintain leads in high-leverage situations, optimizing late-inning matchups and preserving team momentum. Analyzing blown saves highlights vulnerabilities, prompting strategic adjustments in pitcher assignments and roster management to minimize lead losses and enhance overall team competitiveness.

Hold Infographic

Blown save vs Hold in Sports - What is The Difference?


About the author. JK Torgesen is a seasoned author renowned for distilling complex and trending concepts into clear, accessible language for readers of all backgrounds. With years of experience as a writer and educator, Torgesen has developed a reputation for making challenging topics understandable and engaging.

Disclaimer.
The information provided in this document is for general informational purposes only and is not guaranteed to be complete. While we strive to ensure the accuracy of the content, we cannot guarantee that the details mentioned are up-to-date or applicable to all scenarios. Topics about Hold are subject to change from time to time.

Comments

No comment yet