Double toe loop vs Double Salchow in Sports - What is The Difference?

Last Updated Feb 2, 2025

The Double Salchow is a challenging figure skating jump performed by taking off from the back inside edge of one foot and completing two full rotations in the air before landing on the back outside edge of the opposite foot. Mastery of this jump requires precise timing, strong edge control, and excellent air position to maintain balance throughout the rotations. Explore the rest of this article to learn tips and techniques to perfect your Double Salchow.

Table of Comparison

Element Double Salchow Double Toe Loop
Type Edge jump Toe jump
Takeoff Back inside edge of the skate Back outside edge with toe pick assist
Rotation Two full rotations in the air Two full rotations in the air
Difficulty Moderate Moderate to slightly easier
Common Usage Basic to intermediate programs Widely used in competitions across levels
Landing Backward on outside edge of opposite foot Backward on outside edge of opposite foot

Introduction to Double Salchow and Double Toe Loop

The Double Salchow involves a takeoff from the back inside edge of one foot and a landing on the back outside edge of the opposite foot, emphasizing edge control and rotational precision. The Double Toe Loop is initiated using a toe pick-assisted takeoff from the back outside edge, offering a more straightforward jump structure favored for its consistency in combination sequences. Both jumps are fundamental elements in figure skating, with the Double Salchow demanding greater edge work and the Double Toe Loop benefitting from the mechanical aid of the toe pick.

Historical Background of Each Jump

The Double Salchow, invented by Ulrich Salchow in 1909, revolutionized figure skating by introducing a jump launched from the back inside edge without the aid of the toe pick. The Double Toe Loop, credited to Bruce Mapes in the 1920s, brought innovation by using the toe pick to vault into the air from the back outside edge. Both jumps have shaped competitive figure skating, with the Salchow emphasizing edge control and the Toe Loop highlighting toe-assisted propulsion.

Technical Differences: Entry and Execution

The Double Salchow jump initiates from a backward inside edge, requiring precise edging and body control to launch off one foot, whereas the Double Toe Loop begins with a backward outside edge and involves a toe pick assist from the opposite foot for takeoff. Execution of the Double Salchow demands smooth edge transitions and balanced timing, emphasizing edge quality, while the Double Toe Loop relies heavily on the toe pick's strength and timing to generate height and rotation. These distinct technical elements influence overall jump mechanics, landing stability, and scoring potential in figure skating performances.

Mechanics of the Takeoff

The Double Salchow takes off from the back inside edge of one foot, relying on edge control and rotational momentum initiated by a strong push from the free leg. In contrast, the Double Toe Loop uses a toe pick-assisted takeoff from the back outside edge of the skating foot, where the skater taps the ice with the opposite toe pick to vault into the air. The takeoff mechanics of the Double Salchow emphasize smooth edge transitions and body alignment, while the Double Toe Loop demands precise timing of the toe pick plunge and explosive knee extension.

Rotational Dynamics in Each Jump

The Double Salchow generates rotational momentum from the backward inside edge takeoff, utilizing angular velocity to achieve two full revolutions in the air, with a strong emphasis on maintaining body alignment and core stability. In contrast, the Double toe loop relies on a toe pick-assisted jump off the backward outside edge, allowing for a quicker, more explosive rotation powered by the toe pick's leverage, which influences the jump's torque and angular acceleration. The distinct rotational dynamics in each jump affect their execution timing, air position, and landing mechanics, critical for optimizing jump height and rotational speed in competitive figure skating.

Landing Techniques and Challenges

The Double Salchow requires landing on the back outside edge of the opposite foot from takeoff, demanding precise edge control and balance to ensure stability upon touchdown. The Double Toe Loop involves a toe-pick assist from the opposite foot during takeoff and landing on the back outside edge of the same foot, presenting challenges in maintaining momentum and absorbing impact cleanly. Both jumps require exceptional air position and core strength, but the Salchow's edge landing often risks inside edge instability, while the Toe Loop's toe pick can complicate timing for a smooth exit.

Scoring and Judging Criteria

The Double Salchow and Double Toe Loop are scored based on their base values and execution quality, with the Double Toe Loop generally assigned a higher base value due to its entry difficulty and takeoff from the back outside edge combined with the toe pick assist. Judges evaluate the Grade of Execution (GOE) for each element, where clean landings, height, and speed increase the score, and errors like under-rotation or step-outs reduce points; the Double Toe Loop often gains higher GOE thanks to its stability and controlled landing. Both jumps contribute differently to technical element score (TES) and overall program components, making strategic selection and execution essential for maximizing points under ISU judging guidelines.

Common Mistakes and Corrections

Common mistakes in the Double Salchow include incomplete edge use and poor takeoff timing, often corrected by emphasizing proper inside edge positioning and controlled weight distribution at the jump's inception. In the Double Toe Loop, skaters frequently struggle with incorrect toepick placement and insufficient rotation speed, which can be improved through focused drills on toepick alignment and enhancing core strength for rotational velocity. Both jumps benefit from off-ice training targeting balance and muscle memory to reduce landing errors and increase overall jump consistency.

Notable Performances in Figure Skating History

The Double Salchow and Double Toe Loop have both played crucial roles in figure skating history, with skaters such as Michelle Kwan executing the Double Salchow with exceptional grace and consistency during the 1998 Winter Olympics. The Double Toe Loop gained prominence through athletes like Midori Ito, who famously combined it with other jumps to achieve technical difficulty in the late 1980s and early 1990s. These jumps remain fundamental in competitive routines, marking key milestones in the evolution of jump techniques and performance artistry in figure skating.

Which Jump is More Difficult? Expert Opinions

The Double Salchow is generally considered more difficult than the Double Toe Loop due to its edge takeoff, requiring precise control and balance on the back inside edge of the skate. Expert opinions highlight that the Double Toe Loop, with its toepick-assisted takeoff, offers more stability and is easier to execute consistently. Biomechanical analyses emphasize the Double Salchow's higher demand for rotational momentum and timing, making it a more challenging jump for skaters.

Double Salchow Infographic

Double toe loop vs Double Salchow in Sports - What is The Difference?


About the author. JK Torgesen is a seasoned author renowned for distilling complex and trending concepts into clear, accessible language for readers of all backgrounds. With years of experience as a writer and educator, Torgesen has developed a reputation for making challenging topics understandable and engaging.

Disclaimer.
The information provided in this document is for general informational purposes only and is not guaranteed to be complete. While we strive to ensure the accuracy of the content, we cannot guarantee that the details mentioned are up-to-date or applicable to all scenarios. Topics about Double Salchow are subject to change from time to time.

Comments

No comment yet