Intonaco vs Cartone in Art - What is The Difference?

Last Updated Feb 2, 2025

Cartone offers versatile packaging solutions combining durability and eco-friendliness to protect your products effectively. Engineered for strength and sustainability, cartone materials reduce environmental impact while maintaining reliable performance during shipping and storage. Discover how choosing the right cartone can enhance your packaging strategy by reading the full article.

Table of Comparison

Feature Cartone Intonaco
Material Heavy paperboard used in traditional fresco painting Plaster mixture applied on walls for frescoes or finishes
Texture Smooth, flexible surface ideal for preliminary drawings Rough to smooth, depending on finish, provides durable base
Use in Art Cartoon (cartone) used as full-scale preparatory drawings Intonaco is the wet plaster layer painted in true fresco technique
Durability Fragile, used mainly for drafting and transferring designs Highly durable, integral part of wall painting structure
Application Drawn, perforated for pouncing to transfer designs onto intonaco Applied wet, painted before drying to fix pigments chemically
Art Historical Significance Essential step in Renaissance fresco creation for design accuracy Core medium of fresco art, preserving masterpieces over centuries

Introduction to Cartone and Intonaco

Cartone is a traditional Italian material commonly used in mural making, consisting of a detailed, full-scale preparatory drawing on paper that guides the application of intonaco. Intonaco refers to the smooth, wet plaster layer applied to walls or ceilings in fresco painting, serving as the surface onto which pigments are directly painted. Understanding the distinction between cartone as a planning tool and intonaco as a working surface is essential in mastering fresco techniques.

Definition and Origins of Cartone

Cartone is a traditional Italian technique involving a heavy paperboard or cardboard sheet used as a template for fresco painting, originating during the Renaissance period. It served as a precise guide for artists to transfer detailed designs onto wall surfaces, particularly in large-scale mural projects. In contrast, intonaco refers to the wet plaster layer applied to walls, acting as the actual painting surface in fresco art.

Understanding Intonaco: Composition and Use

Intonaco is a traditional plaster layer consisting primarily of lime, sand, and water, known for its smooth finish and breathability, making it ideal for both interior and exterior wall applications. This mixture allows for effective moisture regulation and durability, distinguishing it from gypsum-based cartone, which is less resistant to environmental factors. Intonaco's composition supports its use as a base layer in fresco painting, where its quick setting time and adhesive properties enhance pigment bonding.

Key Differences Between Cartone and Intonaco

Cartone is a type of thick, durable cardboard used primarily for crafting and packaging, while intonaco is a fine plaster layer applied on walls or ceilings in fresco painting and construction. Cartone's key properties include rigidity and lightweight composition, making it ideal for structural support, whereas intonaco provides a smooth, adhesive surface for paint and enhances wall durability. Unlike cartone, intonaco's chemical composition allows it to harden and bond with masonry, serving both aesthetic and protective functions in building construction.

Applications of Cartone in Art and Architecture

Cartone, a detailed full-scale paper drawing, is widely used in art and architecture for creating precise designs and templates before final execution on murals, frescoes, or fresco-like intonaco plaster surfaces. This technique allows artists to transfer intricate compositions onto intonaco smoothly, ensuring accuracy and aiding in large-scale artistic projects such as Renaissance frescoes. Cartone enhances the planning process of architectural decorations and complex wall paintings by providing a tangible guide that integrates seamlessly with the wet intonaco application.

Intonaco in Fresco Painting Techniques

Intonaco is the final, smooth layer of plaster applied in fresco painting techniques, providing a suitable surface for pigment absorption and durability. It is typically composed of fine lime and sand, allowing the artist to work quickly while the plaster is still wet for optimal color fixation. Unlike cartone, which serves as a detailed preparatory drawing, intonaco is essential for the actual paint application in buon fresco, ensuring long-lasting and vivid mural artwork.

Material Properties: Cartone vs Intonaco

Cartone, a lightweight fiberboard made from recycled paper pulp, offers excellent insulation and flexibility but lacks the durable surface hardness found in Intonaco, a traditional plaster made from lime, sand, and water. Intonaco provides superior breathability, moisture resistance, and a strong, weatherproof finish ideal for exterior applications, while Cartone is better suited for interior, decorative, or temporary uses due to its lower mechanical strength. The porous nature of Intonaco allows for better vapor permeability, preventing mold, whereas Cartone's organic composition requires additional treatment for moisture protection.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Cartone

Cartone offers excellent moisture resistance and lightweight properties, making it ideal for interior wall applications where easy installation and flexibility are essential. However, it has lower durability compared to Intonaco, being more susceptible to impact damage and less effective for exterior use. The material's quick drying time and cost-effectiveness are balanced by limited thermal insulation and lower fire resistance compared to traditional plaster finishes.

Pros and Cons of Using Intonaco

Intonaco, a traditional plaster applied in multiple thin layers, offers excellent breathability and durability, making it ideal for historic building restoration and environments prone to humidity. Its natural composition provides superior adhesion and a smooth finish but requires skilled labor and longer drying times compared to Cartone, which is quicker to install and more cost-effective. However, Intonaco's resistance to cracking and ability to regulate indoor humidity often outweigh these drawbacks for long-term structural integrity.

Choosing the Right Material: Cartone or Intonaco?

Choosing the right material between Cartone and Intonaco depends on the specific requirements of your project; Cartone offers lightweight, flexible properties ideal for decorative panels and temporary installations, while Intonaco provides robust durability and excellent adhesion suited for permanent wall finishes. Cartone's ease of shaping and installation makes it a preferred choice for intricate designs, whereas Intonaco's cement-based composition ensures resistance to weather and wear, enhancing structural integrity. Assess factors such as environmental exposure, desired texture, and longevity to select the optimal material for your surface finishing needs.

Cartone Infographic

Intonaco vs Cartone in Art - What is The Difference?


About the author. JK Torgesen is a seasoned author renowned for distilling complex and trending concepts into clear, accessible language for readers of all backgrounds. With years of experience as a writer and educator, Torgesen has developed a reputation for making challenging topics understandable and engaging.

Disclaimer.
The information provided in this document is for general informational purposes only and is not guaranteed to be complete. While we strive to ensure the accuracy of the content, we cannot guarantee that the details mentioned are up-to-date or applicable to all scenarios. Topics about Cartone are subject to change from time to time.

Comments

No comment yet