Axial force vs Bending moment in Engineering - What is The Difference?

Last Updated Feb 2, 2025

Bending moment refers to the internal force within a beam or structural element that causes it to bend under load. Understanding the bending moment is crucial for designing safe and efficient structures capable of withstanding various forces. Explore the rest of the article to learn how bending moment affects your engineering projects and the methods used to calculate it accurately.

Table of Comparison

Parameter Bending Moment Axial Force
Definition Force causing rotation about a section, creating bending stress Force acting along the longitudinal axis, causing tension or compression
Unit Newton-meter (N*m) Newton (N)
Effect on structure Induces bending stress and curvature Generates normal stress along the axis
Stress type Flexural stress Axial normal stress
Typical application Beams, cantilevers under loads causing bending Columns, ties, or members under direct load
Critical for Deflection and bending failure Buckling and axial failure

Introduction to Bending Moment and Axial Force

Bending moment refers to the internal moment that induces bending of a structural element due to applied loads, causing tension and compression within the material. Axial force is the force acting along the longitudinal axis of the member, either in tension or compression, influencing its stability and deformation. Understanding the interaction between bending moment and axial force is critical for designing safe and efficient beams, columns, and other structural components.

Fundamental Definitions and Concepts

Bending moment refers to the internal moment that induces bending stresses within a structural element when subjected to transverse loads, causing it to curve. Axial force is the force applied along the longitudinal axis of a structural member, resulting in either tension or compression without inducing bending. Understanding the interplay between bending moments and axial forces is crucial for assessing combined loading scenarios affecting beam-columns and ensuring structural stability and safety.

Differences Between Bending Moment and Axial Force

Bending moment refers to the internal moment that causes a beam or structural element to bend, while axial force is the direct force applied along the longitudinal axis, causing compression or tension. Bending moments generate stresses that vary across the cross-section, with maximum values occurring at the outer fibers, whereas axial forces produce uniform stress distribution across the cross-section. Understanding the differences is crucial for structural analysis, as bending moments affect deflection and curvature, whereas axial forces influence stability and overall load-bearing capacity.

Sources and Causes in Structural Elements

Bending moment in structural elements is primarily caused by external loads applied perpendicular to the longitudinal axis, such as concentrated loads, distributed loads, or moments, leading to bending stresses within beams and columns. Axial force results from loads applied along the longitudinal axis, including tension or compression forces from gravity loads, prestressing, or thermal expansion effects, creating uniform stress distribution across cross-sections. Sources of bending moments often include lateral loads like wind or seismic actions, while axial forces arise from vertical loads, structural self-weight, and load transfer between connected members.

Effects on Structural Behavior

Bending moment generates curvature in structural elements, inducing tensile and compressive stresses across the cross-section, significantly affecting beam deflection and potential cracking. Axial force primarily influences the overall stability by causing uniform compression or tension, impacting buckling resistance and axial load capacity. The interplay between bending moments and axial forces determines the combined stress distribution, critical for designing safe and efficient columns, beams, and frames under complex loading conditions.

Mathematical Formulation and Calculation

Bending moment and axial force are fundamental structural analysis parameters governed by the equations M = F x d for bending moment, where M represents the moment, F is the force applied perpendicular to the lever arm, and d is the distance from the pivot point. Axial force, denoted as N, acts along the longitudinal axis of a member and is typically calculated using N = s x A, with s being the normal stress and A the cross-sectional area. These mathematical formulations enable precise quantification of internal stresses and design verification in beams and columns subjected to combined loading conditions.

Graphical Representation and Diagrams

Graphical representation of bending moment versus axial force typically involves interaction diagrams or combined loading charts that plot bending moment on one axis and axial force on the other to illustrate structural member capacity under simultaneous loads. These diagrams help engineers visualize failure envelopes and determine safe loading combinations by showing regions of tension, compression, and bending effects. Common forms include P-M interaction curves for columns, where axial force (P) is plotted vertically and bending moment (M) horizontally, aiding in design optimization and structural integrity assessment.

Real-World Applications and Examples

Bending moment and axial force both play critical roles in structural engineering, particularly in the design of beams, columns, and bridges to ensure stability and load-bearing capacity. In real-world applications, bending moments occur in beams subjected to loads causing them to bend, such as in bridge spans and cantilevered structures, while axial forces are predominant in columns and truss members experiencing compression or tension. For example, skyscraper columns must resist high axial compressive forces from the building's weight, whereas bridge girders experience significant bending moments due to traffic loads and environmental factors like wind and earthquakes.

Design Considerations and Safety Factors

Bending moment and axial force significantly influence structural design considerations, requiring precise calculation of load combinations to ensure stability and integrity. Engineers apply safety factors specific to both bending and axial stresses to prevent failure due to material yielding or buckling, adhering to standards like AISC or Eurocode. Accurate assessment of these forces optimizes cross-sectional geometry and material selection, enhancing durability and safety under dynamic and static loading conditions.

Summary and Key Takeaways

Bending moment and axial force are critical parameters in structural engineering that influence the design and analysis of beams and columns. The bending moment causes flexural stress resulting in beam curvature, while axial force induces compressive or tensile stress along the member's length. Understanding their interaction is essential for assessing structural stability, load-bearing capacity, and preventing failure modes such as buckling or yielding.

Bending moment Infographic

Axial force vs Bending moment in Engineering - What is The Difference?


About the author. JK Torgesen is a seasoned author renowned for distilling complex and trending concepts into clear, accessible language for readers of all backgrounds. With years of experience as a writer and educator, Torgesen has developed a reputation for making challenging topics understandable and engaging.

Disclaimer.
The information provided in this document is for general informational purposes only and is not guaranteed to be complete. While we strive to ensure the accuracy of the content, we cannot guarantee that the details mentioned are up-to-date or applicable to all scenarios. Topics about Bending moment are subject to change from time to time.

Comments

No comment yet